My roommate Garrick is a fan of Real Betis, a Seville-based soccer club with an eclectic roster that competes against household names like Barcelona and Real Madrid. Every time Betis plays, Garrick sits in front of our TV and yells a mixture of curses, cheers, and, most interestingly to me, prayers. He isn’t particularly religious—he describes himself as staunchly atheistic until the definition of God is stretched so far it’s nearly unrecognizable as traditional Abrahamic religion. Still, when Real Betis’ forward, Troy Parrott, strikes the ball and it rips towards the opposing team’s goal, a prayer escapes his lips.
I have observed something similar in many of my friends. They live largely secular lives, sometimes consciously, largely unconsciously, yet become spiritual in the domain of sport. As we approach the Harvard vs. Yale football game, the phenomenon seems to appear even more often. I hear people make assertions about the game based on nothing but faith. These appeals to a higher power take different forms: a quick look to the sky before stepping on the field, a strict game-day routine, or even the deep but unfounded belief that victory is destined.
By contrast, others stay grounded in probability. They calculate the odds of Harvard winning based on each team’s performance this season, the results of past matchups, and what others seem to be saying. They have no game-day superstitions, their belief about the match’s result is explainable with evidence, and they don’t invoke a deity on fourth and goal.
This betrays an important disjunction in our psyche between the rational mind and the mind that yearns for something to believe in.
Global religious participation, which I use as a proxy for general theistic sentiment, has declined on average since the 1980s, largely driven by the Western world. This seems explainable by several factors, such as a more globalized world bringing about relativist theories of belief (i.e., exposure to different cultures makes us question whether there is only one “correct” culture), and the gradual degradation of religion through science. Many are more convinced by, and even comforted by, a rational and scientific picture of the world.
Carl Jung articulates this well in his book “Man and His Symbols.” “There are no longer any gods whom we can invoke to help us. The great religions of the world suffer from increasing anemia, because the helpful numina have fled from the woods, rivers, and mountains, and from animals, and the god-men have disappeared underground into the unconscious,” Jung writes. Scientific advancements, like Copernicus’s proposal of heliocentrism (meaning the Earth revolves around the Sun, not the other way around) in the 1500s, have disarmed religion of much of its explanatory power and, in the process, damaged its credibility.
“Our present lives are dominated by the goddess Reason, who is our greatest and most tragic illusion. By the aid of reason, so we assure ourselves, we have ‘conquered nature,’” Jung continues. In many ways, our conversion to the church of Reason has not been a leap from faith to logic, but instead a reallocation of faith. Rather than placing it in the hands of a metaphysically ambiguous being or force that we can never really know, we choose to place our faith in the scientists and researchers who can give us more tangible explanations for the world.
Yet still, this supposedly silly, illogical faith that we are so sure we have outgrown persists. It pokes its tendrils out of our subconscious as the final seconds of the game tick down, and it surfaces when our team’s quarterback throws a Hail Mary. Despite the increase in disciples of atheism, during times of uncertainty we still appeal to the gods we rebuke.
I wish I could say that this has pushed me to re-evaluate the validity of faith as a concept. I am embarrassed to admit that I pride myself on holding no faith and living a life guided entirely by rational decision-making or subconscious influence. Reason and logic feel objective, existing outside the individual. While every religion feels contestable, I find solace in the proven, irrefutable assertions of physics, biology, and chemistry.
Sometimes I do get FOMO, though. I become jealous of my friends who can experience something like true love as magical, rather than as a complex biological and chemical process. They watch a football game as if God is watching over their shoulder. They imbue these things with a sanctity that transcends the physical world, and I think the feelings they experience are much more potent as a result.
Perhaps Jung is on to something, and my confidence in reason is nothing more than well-concealed faith. Perhaps science is “right” to me because it is familiar and easy to grasp, rather than being objectively “true.” Perhaps the fortress of facts and data I have erected around myself to defend and justify my decisions is not logically impregnable.
Whatever the case, I don’t care to find out. For the time being, I am content in my fortress, cold and void of magic as it is. I won’t buy into superstition come game-day, and I won’t say a prayer if the game gets close. Instead, I hope someone reading this studies this phenomenon and presents an explanation for why one or the other is right that my mind can comfortably wrap itself around.
Elliot Hunter Chung ’29 (elliotchung@college.harvard.edu) is very confused.
