Throughout history, sports have been widely seen as something that brings people together, allowing onlookers to escape the monotony of daily life, the uncertainty of global crises, and more. Harvard-Yale is no different. However, The Game has never been as isolated from the complexities of the outside world as spectators might hope. Since the rivalry’s inception, public health, war, and politics have spilled into the tradition.
The Harvard-Yale rivalry Game has been held annually since 1875, with few exceptions. At the beginning of the rivalry, football was more a mix of modern soccer and rugby. Yale’s style of playing football resembled soccer, while Harvard’s mimicked rugby. When the schools first played, the match was played in Harvard’s style. Yale preferred Harvard’s style of football and soon adopted it. As this primitive version of the sport spread, it evolved away from rugby and toward the American football tradition we know and love today.
At the beginning of the 21st century, Harvard dominated in The Game, winning every matchup but one from 2001 to 2015. However, in recent years, the tide has turned, with the Yalies winning the last four installments of The Game. Given this recent track record, the upcoming Game carries even greater stakes than usual for the Crimson as we fight to reclaim our former glory.
Throughout this historic rivalry, Harvard students have worked to keep the tradition alive, even in tough times. In the weeks leading up to The Game of 1894, the excitement could be felt across Harvard’s campus. Harvard students hoped for a comeback in the rivalry, since Yale had shut the team out for the past three years. From 1889 to the fateful 1894 Game, the contest had been held in neutral territory, at Hampden Park in Springfield, MA. Spectators were expecting a riveting Game, but they got a much more violent show.
Yale scored their first touchdown two minutes into The Game after blocking Harvard’s punt. Their next touchdown came after the Crimson failed to punt the ball away from their end zone. Neither of Yale’s scores came from their play; both resulted from Harvard’s recklessness.
Later in the game, Harvard scored on a safety, but Referee Boviard disallowed the two points, claiming his whistle blew before the play. Referee Boviard disallowed another five points for Harvard in the second half. Harvard’s only points came from a respectable touchdown, followed by a missed goal kick, which made the final score 12-4 Yale. After the game, it was generally agreed that Harvard played better but lost due to controversial referee calls and bad luck.
Over the course of The Game, Fred T. Murphy, Yale’s right tackle, sustained a severe head injury that landed him in the hospital and started an unfounded rumor that he had died. Several players sustained head injuries, while others left The Game with broken legs, dislocated collarbones, and broken noses.
The 1894 game was later dubbed the “Hampden Park Bloodbath.” “It was a game in which an unusual amount of bad blood and foul playing was shown,” explained the “New York Times.” “The players were less orderly and well-behaved, however, as scrimmages of all kinds were frequent occurrences, and fully one-half of the players suffered injuries of a more or less serious nature,” the “New York Times” wrote.
“[T]he number of injuries caused by unnecessary roughness prolonged [The Game] far beyond the allotted time and acted as a severe damper upon the enthusiasm of the spectators,” noted the “Yale Daily News.”
While the injuries initially seemed severe, all was relatively well in the end. A doctor on the team described the injuries as “greatly exaggerated.” The top priority seemed to be the players’ ability to play in an upcoming match against the University of Pennsylvania later that week, and most injured players were judged to be fit to play by then.
Still, The Game was suspended for two years for the 1895 and 96 seasons, as sources like the “New York Times” and the “Harvard Crimson” predicted. “Even the most enthusiastic devotee of football admitted that the play to-day will do much to injure the game, and may call for interference from the college authorities,” the “New York Times” speculated. The “Harvard Crimson” had similar speculations, publishing a short article titled “Football in Danger at Yale.” The tradition resumed only in 1897, when Yale returned to face Harvard and tied at Soldiers Field.
The Game of 1894 is only a fraction of football’s violent history. From 1904-1905, there were 37 player deaths and 296 serious injuries at all levels of football nationally. The forward pass, integral to modern football, was illegal until 1906. As in rugby, players gained yardage by moving the ball on foot or relying on lateral or backward passes. At the time, the game involved little protective gear, forcing players to put their bodies on the line to advance the ball.
Some argue that the construction of Harvard Stadium led to the legalization of the forward pass. During the horrific 1905 season, President Theodore Roosevelt, class of 1880, called a meeting to establish safer rules to save the future of football. One proposal was to widen football fields by 40 feet to reduce pileup tackles.
Harvard immediately shot down this suggestion. The reason? Harvard Stadium had been built three years earlier and could not accommodate a wider field. The university’s football team was so influential that the idea was rejected entirely. After more deliberation, the committee arrived at a different major rule change: legalizing the forward pass.
The Harvard-Yale Game continued annually until 1917, when it was formally suspended for 1917 and 1918 not because of intercollegiate rivalry, but because of World War I. To keep the tradition alive, however, only first-year students competed. For legal purposes, the team was called the “Informals.” Unfortunately, the Informals lost to the Yale Newport Naval Reserves, 14–0.
As the war progressed, more and more students went into the service. Those still at the college dedicated countless hours to military training. With so much effort devoted to fighting the war, students and coaches lacked the time to maintain collegiate football. “Can this time be spared from our ever-increasing efforts to win the war? Most obviously it cannot,” the “Harvard Crimson” wrote in 1918.
Similarly, World War II suspended The Game in 1943 and 1944. Harvard athletics transitioned to an informal structure as the athletics facilities were turned over for military training, and, notably, some of Harvard’s athletic coaches entered the military service.
Another disruption of The Game occurred in 1963 when President John F. Kennedy ’40 was assassinated the day before the Harvard-Yale Game. Once the news broke, the Game was postponed, and officials from both universities said it was unlikely to be rescheduled that year. However, The Game was rescheduled a week later. It was held in New Haven, and Yale won 20–6.
The most recent canceled Harvard-Yale Game was in 2020 because of the COVID-19 pandemic. In July 2020, the Ivy League suspended fall sports, including football. That year, The Game did not take place for the first time since World War II.
Knowing the complex history of The Game makes the tradition feel more powerful, highlighting its importance to the Harvard community. Across centuries, Harvard students, like those attending the College today, have found pride and joy in the annual tradition. Even in challenging times, students have done all they can to keep this wonderful Game alive.
Kathleen Shovlin ’29 (klshovlin@college.harvard.edu) is excited to watch The Game.
